Skip to Main Content
Buena Vista University

Library DIY

Welcome to the Library DIY, created to help you walk through some of the most commonly asked research and library questions!

Identify peer-reviewed articles

Peer-reviewed publications (sometimes called scholarly, academic, or refereed) have gone through a review process by experts in the field before being published. Library databases are good places to locate peer-reviewed articles, though not all sources found in those resources are peer-reviewed.

These strategies can help you determine if an article is peer-reviewed.   

Learn more about the journal your article was published in.

  • If you found the article in a database: 
    • there may be an icon on the left side of the source description that indicates the source  type (e.g., scholarly article, magazine article, scholarly book). Peer-reviewed articles articles are usually published in scholarly journals and sometimes in scholarly books.
    • clicking on the journal title may give you more information about the journal and whether it is is peer-reviewed.
       
  • Google the title of the journal and locate the publisher's website for the journal. Then look for an editorial policy page or a page for authors. This page should also indicate whether articles go through a peer review process.
     
  • WARNING: Peer-reviewed journals publish some articles that are not peer-reviewed. For example, book reviews, theatre reviews, obituaries, and editorials are published in peer-reviewed journals but the individual article does not go through the peer-review process. You need to look at the article in the peer-reviewed journal and determine if it is an opinion-based article (like a review) or if it is a research-based article. A peer-reviewed article should be longer than just a couple of pages and should include a bibliography.

In many databases you can limit your search to only peer-reviewed articles. 

  • Look for a checkbox that limits a search to scholarly (peer-reviewed) articles (either on the initial search page or on the results page),
  • Search in a database or journal that only contains peer-reviewed articles. (Read about the database or journal to identify the nature of its publications.)